Trying to use AirPlay to stream from my MacBook to my Apple TV, but it’s not working. The devices are on the same Wi-Fi, but I can’t get the screen to mirror or videos to play. Need step-by-step help to get AirPlay working between my Mac and Apple TV.
Quick Start: Streaming From Mac to Apple TV With AirPlay
So, you wanna beam your Mac’s display over to your Apple TV, huh? Well, fasten your seatbelt because it’s easier than remembering your Netflix password—if everything’s playing nice.
Here’s How to Sling Your Screen
Look, Apple made this so that even your granddad who still calls you to ask how to copy-paste can do it. All you gotta do is:
- Make sure both your Mac and your Apple TV are on the same Wi-Fi network (I know it sounds obvious, but you’d be surprised how many times that’s the issue).
- Tap that little ‘Control Center’ button right at the top right corner of your Mac’s screen.
- Hit ‘Screen Mirroring’. Your Apple TV should just pop up as an option.
- Click it, and bam—your desktop is now filling up the big screen.
If you want to stop, just click the same icon and disconnect. Set it and forget it.
Buffering Drama: The Unexpected Plot Twist
Sometimes, it’s not all smooth jazz. Ever get that spinning wheel of doom while streaming? Yeah, me too. If you’re trying to stream a weird file format (like those random .mkv or .flv files everyone has lying around), it’s not always a pretty picture. Once I tried to AirPlay an old concert video and it looked like a slideshow in slow motion.
For Those ‘It Just Works’ Moments: Level Up With a Media Player
So, after a few rounds of cursing at built-in utilities, I stumbled across something called Elmedia Player. I downloaded it thinking, “Can’t be worse, right?” Turns out, it just plays basically anything I throw at it—AVI, MKV, WMV, you name it.
Playing videos with subtitles, or rare music videos from sketchy corners of the internet that normally make QuickTime choke? Elmedia eats them for breakfast, and it actually works with AirPlay directly from within the app. Save yourself some headaches—seriously.
Summing It Up: Why Fiddle Around?
You could try to wrestle every unsupported video codec into submission… or just let a robust video player do it for you. The Mac-to-Apple TV AirPlay journey is mostly painless, but if you want it to be bulletproof, you might want to check out Elmedia Player. It’s become my default for stuff I actually want to see on the TV without fuss.
That’s my two cents, hope it saves you a few hours and a lot of yelling at your screen.
4 Likes
Honestly, AirPlay SHOULD be as simple as @mikeappsreviewer lays it out, but Apple’s idea of “it just works” often translates to “it worked for the demo, then never again.” I gotta disagree on the always-smooth jazz part—my own MacBook and Apple TV had weeks where AirPlay decided it was on vacation and I was left staring at the spinning wheel longer than I’ve spent watching actual TV.
Anyway, here’s my alternative checklist for when AirPlay doesn’t show your Apple TV in the mirroring list (or fails to connect):
- Software Updates: First off, check that both your macOS and Apple TV have the latest updates. Apple sneaks in magic AirPlay fixes all the time, but they don’t always tell you.
- Reboot-a-palooza: Old-school, but try turning your Mac, your Apple TV, and even your router/modem off and on again. Sometimes AirPlay’s just moody.
- Firewall Gremlins: If you’ve got a super restrictive firewall setup (check System Settings > Network > Firewall), AirPlay might get blocked, especially if “Block all incoming connections” is checked.
- Bluetooth: I know it’s AirPlay (aka Wi-Fi), but for continuity and fast device discovery, Apple uses Bluetooth connections too. Make sure Bluetooth is ON on both devices.
- Same Apple ID: Quick sanity check—sign in with the same Apple ID on both your MacBook and Apple TV, or at least make sure you’re not on some guest Wi-Fi.
- AirPlay Settings on Apple TV: Go to Settings > AirPlay and HomeKit on the Apple TV. Ensure AirPlay is ON and set to “Everyone on the Same Network” or “Anyone.”
If all else fails, I side-eye the codec issue too. Like, if you’re trying to stream a file and it just stutters or AirPlay bails, there’s a fair chance it’s one of those formats QuickTime can’t handle. That’s where Elmedia Player really is a game-changer—and not just hype. Drag any crazy file in, choose AirPlay, and it’ll almost always Just Work™.
Not to rain on anyone’s parade but sometimes even that won’t fix things—if your Wi-Fi signal is garbage, AirPlay still turns into a pixelated mess (I gave up and used a long HDMI cable once, like a caveman). If you’re on a crowded network, try moving closer to your router or, dare I say, kick off other freeloading devices.
So: update, reboot, check settings/firewalls, use better players like Elmedia for oddball files, and remember—sometimes, the old-school fixes beat the “magical” Apple way. Anyone else still stuck in reboot-loop land with AirPlay, or is it just me?
Not gonna lie, AirPlay’s “it just works” vibe is a beautiful lie half the time. @mikeappsreviewer and @viaggiatoresolare nailed most of the big rocks, but let’s cut the fluff for those of us who just want TV and snacks, not a troubleshooting degree.
If you’ve tried Control Center → Screen Mirroring and Apple TV still plays hide-and-seek, but your Wi-Fi’s not the problem—bet it’s some Mac voodoo. The firewall thing is absolutely real. Had mine on “automagically managed,” and it still blocked AirPlay for no reason. Just disabling the firewall for five minutes revealed the Apple TV, then I toggled it back on and AirPlay kept working. Dumb stuff, but it works.
Now, here’s my beef. Everyone says “just make sure you’ve got the right formats.” But it’s nearly 2024 and we’re still battling codecs? I say, instead of obsessing over .mp4 this or .mov that, just grab Elmedia Player. No joke. I thought it was another random video app, but it streams literally everything. You can even throw blown-out old AVI files at it and they play smooth, subtitles and all. Sorry not sorry, but QuickTime is pure pain by comparison.
One more weird one—check if you turned on AirPlay Display as a separate desktop or as a mirror. Sometimes, if you “extend” instead of “mirror,” you’ll think nothing’s happening, when in fact your desktop just shifted over and the taskbar disappears like Houdini.
If after all this you’re still stuck, reset the Apple TV’s network, forget the network on your Mac, and reconnect. Bonus tip (learned the hard way): some routers have client isolation enabled, which keeps devices apart even on the same Wi-Fi. If your router talks “guest mode,” turn that off.
So yeah, updates, firewall off/on, forget & reconnect networks, and Elmedia Player for the win on weird files. If even that fails, Airplay is trolling you and there’s no shame in HDMI.